(c) illarterate
A couple of days ago,
Liverpool FC Managing Director, Ian Ayre, stated that he only felt it fair that his club should have the right to negotiate its own overseas TV deals. Whilst
this is not usual fayre for a criminology blog, notions of social harm come to
mind.
Ayre is concerned that his
club, along with the other more powerful Premiership clubs, will struggle to
compete with their illustrious Spanish counterparts if they do not receive a
greater share of overseas revenue. He contends that it is not the Premier
League per se that attract overseas viewers, but the more well-known teams. At
present, the deal is that all 20 premiership clubs receive an equal share of
the Premier League’s foreign rights TV deal.
Football finance expert, Geoff
Mesher, and Wigan Athletic Chairman, Dave Whelan, have pointed to the damage it
could cause to competition within the Premier League. Whelan suggested that it could lead to its demise, as very few clubs could challenge for the top honours.
Whilst it is very likely
that it would kill competition within
Matchday ticket prices have soared by up to 1000% in the two decades since the inception of the
Premier League. It has priced many traditional fans out of stadia. Many fans
are local to the team that they follow, and to commit to following their team
already requires a vast amount of money. If Ayre’s proposal were to go through,
and the less glamorous clubs increased ticket prices, local supporters are
going to be less likely to pay more money to watch games that are meaningless
in terms of winning honours.
Clubs now operate
competitively in the commercial and sporting market places. Although modern
football clubs are more commercially minded than they used to be, they are not
commercial businesses. The majority are not brands. They do not attract passing
customers. They belong, and rely on, the support of their local communities. If
competition is killed off on the field of play, it is equally likely to kill
off financial health. Clubs may well end up going bankrupt.
And it is in the context
of competition that I am reminded of the effects that the closure of coal mines
had on their local communities. If these clubs were to go to the wall, it would
have a significant impact on local communities. Not just in terms of the passing of the hopes and dreams of fans, but in terms of loss of revenues and jobs for other local businesses that work in and around these clubs, and the community projects that clubs invest in. The social harm caused would be palpable.
Fortunately, this proposal
is unlikely to go through the next time that foreign overseas television rights
come up for discussion. But that does not mean that it will never happen.
|
Blinkered Justice is a criminology blog that casts a critical eye on the construction of crime and justice in the UK and beyond.
Blinkered Justice articles also appear on CrimeTalk and Government In The Lab
Friday, 14 October 2011
Sky's the limit
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment